Lucy's Cafe Menu

If you’re curious about what makes mornings in North Prairie a little brighter, take a look at the Lucy's Cafe Menu. Tucked along Main Street at 132 N Main St, North Prairie, WI 53153, Lucy’s Cafe serves up the kind of comfort food that feels familiar from the very first bite. The menu leans into hearty breakfasts-think fluffy pancakes, golden omelets packed with your favorite fillings, and crispy hash browns done just right.

Then again, it’s not only about breakfast. There’s a solid lineup of burgers, sandwiches, and homestyle plates that make lunchtime just as tempting. Portions are generous without being over the top, and the flavors stick to what works: fresh ingredients, simple recipes, and that unmistakable small-town diner touch. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick coffee or settling in for a relaxed meal with friends, the variety here makes it easy to find something you’ll come back for again.

CHICKEN SANDWICH SHOP

Chicken Cordon Bleu
A large, tender breast of chicken, ham, and Swiss cheese served on a toasted bun
US$14.70
Grilled Or Crispy Chicken
Chicken breast served your way on a toasted bun with tomatoes, lettuce, onions, pickles and side of mayonnaise
US$14.70
Lucys Chicken Sandwich
With grilled chicken breast, Mexican chorizo, pepper jack cheese and avocado
US$15.75
Gabbys Chicken Sandwich
With crispy chicken, bacon, Swiss cheese and avocado
US$15.75

A LA CARTE

Gyro Meat
US$7.35
Corned Beef Hash
US$7.35
Ham
US$6.30
Sausages Patty
US$6.30
Sausages
US$6.30
Bacon
US$6.30
1 Egg
US$3.15
Raisin Toast
US$4.20
Sourdough Toast
US$3.68
RyeToast
US$3.68
Multi-Grain Toast
US$3.68
White Toast
US$3.68
Dinner Roll
US$2.10
Hash Browns
US$6.30
English Muffin
US$4.20
Sausages Gravy
US$4.20
Hollandaise Sauce
US$4.20
Avocado
US$3.15

Sub Sandwiches

Vegetable Sub
With lettuce, tomato, onions, avocado, thin slices of cucumbers, choice of cheese and mayonnaise
US$14.70
Turkey Sub
With turkey, lettuce, tomato, onions, avocado, choice of cheese and mayonnaise
US$15.75
Ham Sub
With ham, lettuce, tomato, onions, avocado, choice of cheese and mayonnaise
US$15.75

Fresh Greens & Such

Athenian Salad
A bed of crispy lettuce tossed with feta cheese, black olives, tomatoes, green peppers, cucumbers, onions, oregano and Greek dressing
US$16.80
Julienne Salad
Fresh salad greens topped with a julienne of turkey, ham, cheese, tomatoes, onions, crowned with green peppers and cucumbers, Served with your choice of dressing.
US$16.80
Chicken Caesar Salad
Sliced grilled chicken breast served on top of fresh crisp lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, green peppers and onions served with Caesar dressing.
US$15.75
Crispy Chicken Salad
With crispy chicken breast served on top of fresh crisp lettuce,tomato,cucumbers,green peppers and onions servede with your choice of dressing
US$15.75
Grilled Chicken Salad
Sliced grilled chicken breast served on top of fresh crisp lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, green peppers and onions served with your choice of dressing.
US$15.75
Chicken Taco Salad
With grilled chicken breast,lettuce,tomato,onions and cheddar cheese in our crisp flour tortilla shell,served with sour cream and salsa
US$15.75
Beef Taco Salad
With ground beef,lettuce,tomato,onions and cheddar cheese in our flour tortilla shell,served with sour cream and salsa
US$15.75

Tortilla Wraps

Cajun Chicken Wrap
With Cajun seasoning chicken,onions,tomato,green peppers,and ranch dressing all mix together
US$14.70
Turkey & Bacon Wrap
With turkey,bacon,lettuce,onions,tomato,green peppers and mayonnaise all mix together
US$15.75
B.L.T. Wrap
With Bacon,lettuce,tomato,onions,green peppers, and mayonnaise all mix together
US$13.65
Chicken Caesar Wrap
With chicken,onions,tomato,green peppers,lettuce and Caesar dressing all mix together
US$14.70
Lucys Chicken Wrap
With Crispy chicken,onions,tomato,green peppers,lettuce,avocado and ranch dressing all mix together
US$14.70
B.L.T. AND AVOCADO WRAP
With Bacon,lettuce,tomato,onions,green peppers,avocado and mayonnaise all mix together
US$14.70

Clubs

B.L.T. Club
With bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
US$14.70
Ham & Cheese Club
With ham, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
US$14.70
Club Classic
With sliced turkey, crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
US$15.75
Lucys BLT Club
With bacon, lettuce, tomato and avocado, mayonnaise
US$15.75

Sandwich

B.L.T. Sandwich
Bacon, tomatoes, lettuce and mayonnaise
US$12.60
Grilled Cheese & Ham Sandwich
US$13.65
Grilled Cheese & Bacon Sandwich
US$13.65
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
With your choice of cheese With bacon or ham
US$11.55
French Dip Sandwich
Roast beef and mozzarella cheese on a toasted roll with au just for dipping
US$14.70
Corned Beef & Swiss Sandwich
Served warm on rye bread with Swiss cheese
US$15.75
Reuben Sandwich
Delicious sliced corned beef topped with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut grilled on rye bread
US$15.75
Gyro Sandwich
On grilled pita with onion, tomato & gyro sauce
US$14.70

Hot Melts

Tuna Melt
Fresh creamy tuna salad served on grilled rye and covered with your choice of melted cheese
US$14.70
Patty Melt
1/2 lb. Black Angus beef patty with choice of melted cheese and grilled onions on grilled rye bread
US$14.70
Chicken Melt
With grilled chicken breast and pita bread and covered with your choice of melted cheese
US$14.70
Turkey Melt
Served with turkey on grilled rye and covered with your choice of melted cheese
US$14.70

Burgers

Burger
1/2 lb Black Angus burger
US$12.60
Bacon & Cheese Burger
1/2 lb Black Angus burger with bacon and choice of cheese
US$14.70
Belt Buster Burger
1/2 lb. Angus Burger with crisp bacon, fried egg, and grilled tomatoes, topped with your choice of melted cheese on a toasted bun
US$16.80
Cheese Burger
1/2 lb Black Angus burger with your choice of cheese
US$13.65
Lucy's Burger
1/2 lb. Angus beef topped with sautéed mushrooms, green peppers, grilled onions and choice of cheese
US$15.75
Mushroom + Swiss Burger
1/2 lb. Angus Burger with Swiss cheese on a toasted bun
US$14.70
Gios Cheeseburger
1/2 lb Black Angus burger With bacon, pepper jack cheese and BBQ sauce
US$14.70
Mexican Cheeseburger
1/2 lb Black Angus burger With Mexican chorizo, pepper jack cheese and avocado
US$14.70

Healthy Choice

Bowl Of Fresh Fruit & Raisin Toast
US$12.60
Bowl Oatmeal & Fruit
Your choice of fresh fruit
$
Bowl Oatmeal
US$7.35

Lucys Combos

Waffle & 2 Eggs & Meat
$
1 French Toast 2 Eggs & Meat
$
2 Pancakes 2 Eggs & Meat
$

Benedicts

Crab Cake Benedict
With crab cake and hollandaise sauce
US$18.90
Florentine Benedict
Sliced tomato, sautéed spinach, mozzarella cheese and hollandaise sauce
US$16.80
Eggs Benedict
With Canadian bacon, hollandaise sauce
US$15.75

Signature Potatoes

Meat-Lover Potatoes
With hash browns, ham, bacon, sausage links, onions, green peppers and mushrooms, topped with mozzarella cheese
US$11.55
Mexican Potatoes
With hash browns, tomatoes, green peppers, onion, Mexican chorizo, pepper jack cheese and sour cream
US$11.55
Lucys Potatoes
With hash browns, green peppers, onion, mushrooms, bacon and topped with cheddar cheese
US$10.50

Crepes

3 Fresh Fruit Crepes
$
2 Fresh Fruit Crepes
$
1 Fresh Fruit Crepe
$
3 Plain Crepes
US$12.60
2 Plain Crepes
US$9.83
1 Plain Crepes
US$7.35

French Toast

1 French Toast & Fresh Fruit
$
2 French Toast & Fresh Fruit
$
3 French Toast & Fresh Fruit
$
3 French Toast
US$11.55
2 French Toast
US$9.45
1 French Toast
US$7.35

Belgium Waffles

Alaskan Waffle
Served with whipped cream topped with ice cream, strawberry and pecans
US$14.70
Chocolate Chip Waffle
US$13.65
Fresh Fruit Waffle
Served with whipped cream, choice of one fresh fruit: blueberry, banana or strawberry and fruit sauce
$
Plain Waffle
US$11.55
Pecan Waffle
US$13.65

Fluffy Pancakes

1 Choc Chip Pancakes
US$8.40
1 Fresh Fruit Pancakes
Served with whipped cream choice of one fruit: blueberry, banana or strawberry and fruit sauce
$
1 Pancakes
US$6.83
1 Pecan Pancakes
US$8.40
1 Pigs-In-A-Blanket
US$8.40
2 Chocolate Chip Pancakes
US$10.50
2 Fruit Pancakes
$
2 Pancakes
US$8.93
2 Pecan Pancakes
US$10.50
2 Pigs In Blanket
Sausage links wrapped with golden pancake
US$10.50
3 Fruit Pancakes
$
3 Pancakes
US$11.03
3 Pigs In Blanket
Sausage links wrapped with golden pancakes
US$12.60

3 Eggs Omelettes

Greek Omelette
Gyro meat, feta cheese, tomato, onion & green peppers
US$14.70
Spinach & Feta Cheese Omelette
With fresh spinach and feta cheese
US$13.65
Western Omelette
Ham, green peppers, onions, tomato and melted cheese
US$15.75
Denver Omelette
Ham, green peppers and onions
US$14.70
Wisconsin Omelette
Made with Swiss, American and cheddar cheese
US$13.65
Mushroom Omelette
With fresh mushrooms and choice of cheese
US$13.65
Vegetarian Omelette
Green peppers, onions, tomato, mushrooms and spinach
US$13.65
Meat Omelette
Choice of bacon or sausage or ham
US$13.65
Cheese Omelette
With your choice of cheese
US$11.55
Mexican Omelette
Tomato, green peppers, onions and chorizo, topped with melted pepper jack cheese, salsa and sour cream
US$16.80

Steak N Eggs

1/2 Lb Ribeye Steak & Eggs
US$19.95
1/2 Lb Chopped Sirloin Steak & Eggs
US$14.70
1/2 Lb New York Steak & Eggs
US$17.85
Sirloin Steak And Eggs
US$15.75

Country Fresh Eggs

One Egg
US$8.40
One Egg Any Style W/ Meat
US$10.50
Two Eggs Any Style W/ Meat
With bacon sausage (links or patties) or ham
US$12.60
2 Eggs Any Style
US$9.45
2 Eggs & Corned Beef Hash
US$14.70
2 Eggs & Gyro Meat
US$13.65

Breakfast Specials

Biscuits & Sausages Gravy
Bringing you the best in southern hospitality!
US$12.60
Biscuits & Sausages Gravy & Eggs
US$13.65
Country Breakfast
2 Eggs any style, bacon, sausage links, one biscuit & sausage gravy and hash browns
US$15.75
Country Fry Steak
2 Eggs any style, hash browns and buttered toast
US$15.75

Breakfast Burritos

Lucys Burrito
Served with diced potatoes, green peppers, onions, sweet corn and cheddar cheese
US$13.65
Vegetarian Burrito
With green peppers, onions, tomato, mushrooms and spinach and cheddar cheese
US$12.60
Mexican Burrito
With Mexican chorizo, onions, green peppers, tomato and cheddar cheese
US$14.70
Meat Burrito
With your choice of meat bacon,sausages or ham
$
Meat Lovers Burrito
With bacon, sausage links, ham and cheddar cheese
US$14.70

Breakfast Sandwiches

Fried Egg Sandwich
With choice of bacon, sausage patty or ham
$
Denver Sandwich
With ham, green peppers and onions
US$12.60

Breakfast Skillets

Meat Lover Skillet
Hash browns topped with sausages, crisp bacon tender ham and melted cheese topped with two eggs any style
US$15.75
Grandpa Skillet
Hash browns with ham, sautéed onions, green peppers and melted cheese topped with two eggs any style
US$14.70
Bellas Skillet
Diced potatoes, green peppers, onions, mushrooms sirloin steak, melted cheese topped with two eggs any style
US$17.85
Gios Skillet
Diced potatoes, green peppers, onions sweet corn Mexican chorizo and melted cheese topped with two eggs any style
US$16.80
Gabbys Skillet
Diced potatoes, green peppers, onions sweet corn topped with melted cheese topped with two eggs any style
US$14.70
Vegetarian Skillet
Hash browns with sautéed onions, green peppers, tomatoes, spinach, mushrooms and choice of melted cheese topped with two eggs any style
US$14.70

Sweet Endings

Malts
(Vanilla, Chocolate or Strawberry)
US$7.35
Scoop Of Ice Cream
US$3.15
Shakes
(Vanilla, Chocolate or Strawberry)
US$7.35

Mexican Favorites

Beef Or Chicken Quesadillas
Prepared with choice of chicken or ground beef, grilled to perfection with melted cheese
US$15.75
Cheese Quesadilla
Grilled to perfection with melted cheese
US$12.60
Vegetarian Quesadilla
Grilled to perfection with melted cheese, green peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom and spinach
US$14.70
Lucys Quesadilla
Diced potatoes, green peppers, onions, sweet corn and melted cheese
US$14.70

Beverages

Coffee
(Regular or Decaf)
US$3.68
Hot Chocolate
(with Whipped Cream)
US$3.68
Milk
US$3.68
Chocolate Milk
US$4.20
Lemonade
US$3.68
Bottled Water
US$1.58
Cranberry Juice
Cranberry Juice
US$4.20
Apple Juice
US$4.20
Orange Juice
Orange Juice
US$4.20
Can Soda PEPSI COLA
US$1.58
Can Soda DIET PEPSI COLA
US$1.58
Can Soda MOUNTAIN DEW
US$1.58

Seafood

Shrimp Basket
Served with cocktail sauce
$
Jumbo Fried Shrimp
Served with cocktail sauce
$

Lucys Soup of the Day

Lucys Soup Of The Day
With saltines crackers and dinner roll
US$0.00

Appetizers

French Fries
US$6.30
Onion Rings
US$9.45
Chicken Strips
US$9.45
Cheese Curds
US$9.45
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available. 📞 +1 262-392-4084